PODCAST

 

This Week in AML

Tech Outages, Transparency, FinCEN's CDD Proposal, and Deutsche Bank’s Scrutiny

A week marked by airline disruptions, ATM outages, and technology failures sets the stage for a broader discussion about operational resilience and risk management. In this episode of This Week in AML, Elliot Berman and John Byrne examine our growing dependence on technology and explore how regulators are responding to emerging risks.

The conversation covers the OCC's latest risk perspective, Federal Reserve Governor Michael Barr's warnings about AI-driven cyber risks, and the ongoing debate over balancing innovation with appropriate safeguards. They also discuss Ireland's move to expand access to beneficial ownership information, concerns about money-laundering risks in the U.S. art market, and a new anti-corruption guidance initiative from GRECO.

The episode then turns to several significant compliance developments, including new allegations involving Deutsche Bank and FinCEN's proposed revisions to Customer Due Diligence requirements. The discussion highlights the ongoing tension between regulatory burden reduction and effective risk management.

 

Tech Outages, Transparency, FinCEN's CDD Proposal, and Deutsche Bank’s Scrutiny - Transcript

Elliot Berman: Hi, John. How are you today?

John Byrne: Good, Elliot. As we're recording, at least today, there's not been any massive outages of some sort. 'Cause as everybody knows, for five or six days we've had planes stop, we've had ATM disruption, the NSA apparently lost some access. If you were on Outlook, you weren't getting emails for a long period of time.

We've seen some statements from folks in the government that say that none of this is connected. We don't know if it is or isn't, but it does tell you a little bit about our reliance on technology, which we all know. But when you put all these things together in a week, it does give you some sense of what would happen if the grid goes down.

Obviously it's not an AML issue, but it's a day-to-day issue and it's something that we'll all continue to follow. Just thought I would highlight the fact that nothing has happened this morning yet, but it's only the middle of the week.

Elliot Berman: That's true. Karen and I were supposed to go to Boston last week coming home on Saturday. We didn't. We ended up canceling the trip, but we probably on the return side, would have gotten caught up in the cascade impact of all the planes being in the wrong places and the pilots being in the wrong places.

John Byrne: Yeah. Actually, we were supposed to go to the Packer game on Sunday and we decided we couldn't make it. We would have left Saturday, so there's no way we would have gotten there anyway.

Elliot Berman: No, that's right. You would have gotten to the airport, realized what the issues were, and called your friends with the tickets and said, "Eh, sorry, won't be able to make it."

John Byrne: That's right. Yeah.

Elliot Berman: I can drive to a Packer game in Green Bay. A little tough for you.

John Byrne: Yes. I don't mind the Packers, but since I'm a Giant fan, no, I don't think that's happening,

Elliot Berman: I understand. You're gonna save your driving hours for New York.

John Byrne: So a bunch of things. Let me start with something, it's not necessarily minor, but just wanna reference that the OCC did their semi-annual risk perspective. The document's about 14 pages long. It goes into the different risks that they assess on interest rates, and credit, cyber security, those types of issues. Nothing in there really jumped out. The update says that, we're still calling it artificial intelligence simplifies cyber security and fraud concerns.

That's referenced there. I will note that in the 14 pages of the risk perspective, Gould, the comptroller, felt it necessary to rename AI SI at least 50 times. So that was one thing that we noticed. But the bottom line is the risks there, nothing mentioning the AML space, but it does mention cyber issues and certainly fraud concerns.

So that's in the risk perspective from the OCC. And related in terms of agency comments, Fed Governor Michael Barr gave a speech before a group in Milan, Italy, a conference on artificial intelligence, and he's spoken on this issue, according to his statement, at least five or six times publicly.

He does have a section in the speech on AI and cyber risk. He has not fallen into the trap of calling it SI. But here's what he says in part. He said, "Incidents this year have shown the risks from AI models acting autonomously, not in alignment with the goals of their human creators, including cyber risks."

"Given a goal, their models have treated security boundaries as obstacles to overcome rather than rules to be followed, raising questions about how effective rules will be against AI agents instructed to follow them." And then he said, "AI models are also revealing vulnerabilities no one dreamed of just a few years ago."

And as he said, "I've spoken before, for example, about how AI can raise cyber risks through the use in creating deepfakes." So he referenced deepfakes and a bunch of other issues. The speech is in its entirety on the Board of Governors website. He gave the speech on November 16th.

Elliot Berman: He did include in the speech that he remains optimistic that AI can improve access and efficiency as long as it's deployed in ways that protect the users. So he wasn't a no AI guy. He was, we have to be really thoughtful and careful, and I think that's certainly a good way to manage risk, to be thoughtful and careful.

John Byrne: Oh, I'll tell you, the comedian Jon Stewart said the other day he thinks AI is Google on cocaine. But obviously we have to both manage it and put around guardrails. And it'll be interesting to see if this new Congress does that in 2027.

Elliot Berman: Yes. Where would you like to go from here? How about Ireland? Let's go to Ireland.

John Byrne: Oh, I'd love to go to Ireland. Can we go right now?

Elliot Berman: I've never been, but I wouldn't mind going. So you and I have talked if not every week, certainly a couple of times a month, about the whole issue of beneficial ownership information. How it's gathered, how it's available, where it's not gathered, and the complex patchwork globally.

Ireland, which has been capturing beneficial ownership through a registration process for a number of years, has opened its registers to journalists, civil society organizations, and academics to access the information. It's introducing a legitimate interest test. So it's not just available on an open website anybody can go and look. But it's recognizing that there are legitimate interests for the public to have at least indirect access through these various groups or categories of folks.

I thought that was interesting, with the backdrop of what we've done here in the US to see other countries and groups of countries moving more toward availability. I guess that would make me cautiously optimistic that over the long run, beneficial ownership information will become more available and more usable.

John Byrne: Staying overseas, there's a post from an recently reported article about the art market in the US. This is from the Center for Art Law, and the piece goes into whether or not the US is now considered a high-risk jurisdiction in terms of the art market. And one analyst said yes, because the art market is currently not subject to AML regulations similar to the UK.

There's a whole piece on it links back to an organization called FCS Compliance. It's a really good article that's been posted there. You can find it on LinkedIn. But the article talks about the guidance issues regarding this. The author is a JD candidate at Harvard Law School. But goes into great detail about how money laundering occurs through the art market. How it has been identified as a potential area for money laundering in the US.

But the conclusion was it was not a priority for the the current Treasury Department, which we've reported on before. The article says that in the UK this could cause some issues. Reading from the conclusion it says that the US art market landscape has significantly shifted and strengthened its regulatory compliance, but it still lacks oversight.

And so it would be worth evaluating whether or not the AML requirements implemented for the antiquities market are going to occur. That hasn't happened yet either. So, interesting area, something that we've talked about from time to time. I just thought because somebody was kind enough to post a piece on that, we'd reference both the article.

Elliot Berman: Yes, it is an issue, and we'll see whether that changes in the US. Right now I think the focus is certainly not in that direction, but it'll be interesting to see where that goes. So, staying in Europe, the Council of Europe's anti-corruption body, which is called the Group of States Against Corruption, or the acronym is GRECO. They published an interesting piece called A Thematic Guide on Codes of Conduct, and this was looking at the value of codes of conduct in governmental agencies in terms of managing corruption that occurs in legislatures and in national level agencies around Europe.

I recommend that people take a look at it if you operate in Europe or as you think about corruption generally and how codes of conduct can be helpful. They go into some detail about what they learned through their fifth round of evaluations. They go around the countries in Europe and do corruption evaluations.

And so this grew out of that with a focus on the codes of conduct. They also talk about how to construct a good code of conduct and and how it should apply to the people that are governed by it. You can go to the GRECO website or the Council of Europe website and find that.

John Byrne: Sticking with corruption-related topics, there's been investigations highlighted by various journalists into Deutsche Bank. And Transparency International has weighed in on this. This was an investigation based on more than 15 million leaked documents. And according to TI, they believe that the reporting details link to major corruption cases, including Malaysia's IMDB affair, South Africa's Gupta state capture scandals, as well as links to Russian oligarch clients.

They add that it raises concerns about correspondent banking and other related issues. This is reported in the major media outlets. The CEO of TI said the following: "Banks are supposed to be the first line of defense against dirty money, not a means of moving it around the world.

Yet these revelations suggest that when profits and compliance collided, profits too often won." So Elliot, there's a lot to unpack here. I would go to several sources, not just what TI has said about these investigations. But obviously, with 15 million documents leaked, there'll be follow-ups, I'm sure. So what else did, did you take away from the Deutsche Bank postings?

Elliot Berman: There was an extensive story in The New York Times. They were one of the organizations involved in doing the investigation. There's also a whistleblower element to this. ... Someone inside who they've talked to.

At the moment the chairman of Deutsche Bank is strongly backing the CEO. And the bank says it does not expect any financial impact from the investigation to be meaningful, although the German finance minister has called on authorities to continue to investigate.

I think the comment you made about TI's comment that when profits and compliance collide, profits win. It was clear that there were people inside Deutsche Bank on the risk side who back, when Russia invaded Crimea and there was a wave of sanctions, and the risk people were identifying the clients that might be subject to the sanctions and therefore we needed to have a unified internal process and response at Deutsche Bank.

And their early warnings one of the stories I read were described as being ignored. And again, it was profits.

John Byrne: I'm assuming there'll be hearings in 2027 on this and related topics.

The other item I wanted to mention that we both talked about, and that's FinCEN issued a proposed rule on CDD earlier this week. And this has gotten a lot of play on LinkedIn. I will frankly say some of the postings tend to be just from the headlines as opposed to actually reading the proposal.

But the proposal does a few things. Again, there's a comment period, a 60-day comment period, but according to the press release from Treasury, it would provide the covered financial institutions can obtain additional information about beneficial owners of a legal entity customer that may be useful in mitigating risk or addressing supervisory concerns.

Sounds, pretty positive, except that it codifies exceptive relief, removing the requirement that covered institutions identify and verify the legal entity each time the customer opens a new account. Some have said that is a great burden reduction. We'll wait to see how that happens.

And then specifies the information that an institution must obtain about each beneficial owner of a legal entity. Now, the thing that it does, it also rejects the notion that banks can use ITINs for identification purposes. Why are they doing that? Because part of the rule proposal also addresses having banks determine whether or not customers, this is my take, whether customers are in fact here legally or not.

So I think that's what underlies all of this, Elliot, from my perspective. It is gonna be interesting to see during the comment process. Like I've said, I've seen some postings sharing the exceptive relief because no one wants to suggest that you should have to document each time there's a new account opened, but obviously there may be some situations where that would make sense.

But the overall theme says you can look at whatever you need to look at to determine risk, that seems broad enough to encompass a lot of areas. What's your take on all of this?

Elliot Berman: I know that least some people are applauding the, you only have to identify beneficial owners at the initial account opening part of the proposal.

I see why we shouldn't necessarily need to do it every time an account's opened, but it feels like one and done is not really a risk-based approach. So if you think about a lot of organizations at the beneficial ownership level. If you open an account on day one and five years later, that organization is still with the same bank, and now they want to open a second account, what's the likelihood that the reported beneficial owners are all still in place and there's no new ones that would fit into that definition?

And my view is low. You don't have to look, is it just strikes me as antithetical to the stated purpose, which is to have a risk-based approach focused on the greatest threats to financial institutions and national security. So are we inviting people to have acceptable beneficial owners open an account and then have the bad actors come in behind them?

And we're now saying you don't have to try to detect that. I don't know. This rule doesn't feel like it's going to accomplish the stated goal at the beginning in the preamble

John Byrne: No, and I've talked to some bankers that have read this so far, and this is the part that gets them concerned operationally. The proposal, I'm reading from the fact sheet, would, however, specify that an Individual Tax Identification Number, the ITIN, as I mentioned before, is not an acceptable substitute for a Social Security number. Additionally, the proposal would explicitly provide that covered institutions may obtain information from a third-party source.

A lot of banks think it's gonna be problematic operationally because of that ITIN prohibition, so we're gonna see how that goes. Even the way the OCC came out and endorsed this proposal was interesting from the perspective of in their press statement, and then Gould really hasn't met an issue that he doesn't issue a press statement for.

Never seen this with any other comptroller, and we've done 40 years of comptrollers, by the way. Starts off by saying this is in alignment with Trump's Executive Order 14406. You never see those sorts of things. But he adds that the OCC welcomes FinCEN's action to streamline CDD.

Bottom line is we'll see how the comments come in. We did expect this was gonna happen before the end of the year, and I wonder, will there be any other final rules that we'll be reporting on before the end of December?

Elliot Berman: There's a list of rules that are, we're still waiting for, so it'll be curious to see. The last one that I wanted to mention is that Revolut, which is an online bank that started in the UK and has been spreading its business efforts around the globe, they've applied for an OCC charter and have preliminary approval.

We'll see if this changes it. An Italian court has placed the European unit of Revolut under judicial administration after finding that convicted mobsters and money launderers had funneled illicit cash through its accounts.

John Byrne: Gee, we thought Revolut was a perfume, so yeah.

Elliot Berman: I didn't realize that online banks thought that money laundering was a product. The action was taken after prosecutors told a Milan court that the bank had been used as a financial reservoir for serious criminals, giving it an unfair advantage over rival institutions who had adequate AML systems. In all these years, I never thought of about it as a competition issue.

But it'll be interesting to see if this impacts the OCC's final determination on a charter. This could have a rippling effect of Revolut's business as it tries to get banking charters or licenses in other places around the world.

We'll see.

John Byrne: By the way, it does remind me, another posting I saw recently was an article about how the OCC has been substantially reduced in terms of staff and examiners, and that's going to impact their ability to do things. Somebody who was a former OCC examiner posted the way, the salaries paid for OCC examiners don't come from government funds.

They actually come from the banks and the fees. And they said, so when DOGE cut all these staff, they weren't saving the government any money. That's a side issue, but it is interesting that agency lost so much expertise, arguably because of issues related to savings when that wasn't the case at all.

Elliot Berman: By the time our audience hears this episode, the November webinar will have streamed and if you look for it by the end of next week, it'll be up on our website, and that's on the impact of FATF evaluations. And you and I are going to sit down with Megan Hodge from US Bank and do a financial crime compliance year-end review on December 17th.

That'll be our last webinar of 2026. By the time people hear this, they should be able to register for that webinar, and we think it'll be a good session, so we encourage you to do that. Anything else, John?

John Byrne: Later today I'm going to sit down with Steve Gurdak, decades long public servant who started his career as a detective and ended up running the SAR review team here in Northern Virginia, and Steve is retiring at the end of the year from that role.

And so I'm going to talk to Steve about his impressions over time, the value proposition of SARs. He was a great private public partnership leader in that his meetings would always bring in experts to talk to both the private and public sectors, and they-- these meetings were standing room only.

So we're going to ask Steve his thoughts. I know he feels strongly that both sides do work well together, and he has some recommendations going forward. So we'll do that interview today. It will run in the next couple of weeks.

Elliot Berman: Sounds great. Next week we're going to run an archive edition, so we hope everybody has a great Thanksgiving and enjoys the holiday with family.

And then we'll be back the week of the 30th with another edition that we'll post on the 4th. John I'm sure I will talk to you between now and then, but have a great Thanksgiving.

John Byrne: Take care, everybody, and stay safe.

Elliot Berman: You too. Bye-bye